Choosing the right toilet paper is crucial; you don’t want to waste money on low-quality rolls that feel harsh or overpriced ones that don’t perform. It’s also important to select a type that dissolves well to prevent plumbing issues. With a variety of options available, from luxurious to eco-friendly, we’ve tested them to identify the best value for your comfort and convenience.
| Image | Product | Feature | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Best Overall
|
Berkley Jensen Ultra Soft Bath Tissue
|
|
Check Price |
|
Best Value
|
Great Value Ultra Soft Toilet Paper
|
|
Check Price |
|
The Softest
|
Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper
|
|
Check Price |
|
The Strongest
|
Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare Toilet Paper
|
|
Check Price |
1. Berkley Jensen Ultra Soft Bath Tissue
BJ’s toilet paper offers excellent value, earning the Good Housekeeping Seal for its superior absorbency and quick-dissolving properties, making it septic-safe. It’s praised for its softness by both consumers and testing machines, and it’s defect-free.
The Berkley and Jensen BJsTP36PK bath tissue is a product that promises both softness and strength. It is a 2-ply premium bath tissue that offers an ultra-soft feel, which is gentle on the skin. The tissue is thick enough to provide a comfortable and absorbent experience, ensuring that users have a satisfactory and hygienic clean.
Septic Safety and Environmental Considerations: This bath tissue is septic-safe, making it a worry-free choice for households with septic systems. It’s designed to dissolve quickly to prevent clogging and maintain the integrity of plumbing systems. Additionally, the product carries the Good Housekeeping Seal, which may provide an extra layer of trust for quality assurance.
Packaging and Value: The package includes 36 rolls, which can be considered a generous amount, likely to cater to family needs or individuals looking for bulk purchases. The price point is positioned to offer value, especially when considering the balance between quality and quantity.
User Feedback: Based on customer ratings, the product has received mixed reviews. Some users have praised the softness and quality of the tissue, while others have noted that it may not be as durable as some other brands like Scott or Charmin. However, it’s important to note that during times of high demand, such as the pandemic, this product has served as a reliable option for consumers.
Comparison with Other Brands: When compared to other brands in the market, such as Charmin Ultra Soft or Cottonelle Ultra Comfort, the Berkley and Jensen bath tissue holds its own in terms of softness and comfort. However, some users may find that they go through rolls quicker than with other brands, which could be a consideration for those looking to maximize usage per roll.
2. Great Value Ultra Soft Toilet Paper
Walmart’s toilet paper offers great value, performing well in thickness, dissolvability, and softness tests, even surpassing pricier brands. It’s strong when dry with good perforation, though less so when wet. Available for online purchase, it can be picked up in-store or delivered from select locations.
Great Value Ultra Strong Toilet Tissue Paper is a product that promises both strength and comfort. It is designed to provide a satisfactory experience without the worry of easy tears or shreds. The tissue paper has been reviewed positively for its durability and quality, with many customers finding it comparable to more expensive brands. It holds up well during use, suggesting that the product lives up to its ‘ultra strong’ claim.
Softness: Despite its strength, this toilet tissue does not compromise on softness. Users have reported that it feels gentle and does not cause irritation, which is an important factor for a product that is used daily. This balance of softness and strength is a key selling point that has been appreciated by consumers.
Dissolvability: An essential aspect of toilet tissue is its ability to dissolve effectively to prevent plumbing issues. While some tests have shown that Great Value Ultra Strong Toilet Tissue Paper may not dissolve as quickly as other brands, it generally performs adequately in this regard. However, those with sensitive plumbing systems may want to consider this factor.
Value for Money: Priced competitively, this product offers good value for money. It is often highlighted as a cost-effective alternative to premium brands, providing a similar level of quality at a lower price point, For budget-conscious consumers, this makes Great Value Ultra Strong an attractive option.
Packaging and Accessibility: The product is available in bulk, which is convenient for households looking to stock up. However, there have been some concerns about the packaging, particularly when ordered online, as it may arrive without a protective box. This is a minor issue but something to be aware of when purchasing.
3. Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper
Charmin toilet paper is exceptionally soft and strong, even when wet, according to both consumer tests and lab equipment. However, its durability may pose issues for septic systems or old plumbing. It’s cost-effective in bulk and a good choice if plumbing isn’t a concern.
Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper is renowned for its exceptional softness and comfort, making it a top choice for those seeking a gentle touch. It has been rated as the softest toilet paper, which is a testament to its plush texture that provides a soothing experience during use.
The product boasts a 2-ply construction, ensuring both strength and softness. Each roll contains 328 sheets, offering a good balance between quantity and quality. The toilet paper’s strength is notable, providing resistance to puncturing, which is an essential feature for effective use.
One of the standout qualities of Charmin Ultra Soft is its disintegration capability. It is designed to break down quickly in water, reducing the risk of clogging pipes and making it suitable for septic systems. This feature is particularly important for those with sensitive plumbing or who are environmentally conscious about their product choices.
In terms of user experience, the Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper excels at providing a comfortable and efficient cleaning process. Its softness is attributed to the judgment of trained panelists, ensuring that the product meets high standards of tactile satisfaction. Additionally, the toilet paper’s ability to disintegrate effectively means that it won’t linger in the plumbing, which is a practical benefit for maintenance and long-term costs.
While the price point may be slightly higher than average, many users find the investment worthwhile for the level of comfort and quality provided. The product’s pleasant eggshell color also adds a subtle aesthetic appeal, blending nicely with modern bathroom color schemes.
4. Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare Toilet Paper
Cottonelle stands out for its strength, both wet and dry, without pilling or layer separation. Its two-ply, rippled design is highly absorbent and soft, offering a balance between plushness and quick dissolution.
Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare Toilet Paper stands out in the market for its combination of softness, strength, and absorbency. This toilet paper is a two-ply bathroom tissue that offers a comforting texture and a reliable clean. It’s designed to be soft on the skin while being strong enough to do its job effectively.
Customers have praised Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare for its soft and comfortable feel, noting that it doesn’t cause any irritation, which is particularly important for those with sensitive skin. The toilet paper’s texture is often described as plush and cushiony, providing a touch of luxury to the everyday necessity.
The strength of the toilet paper is also a highlight, with users appreciating that it doesn’t tear easily during use. This durability is balanced with a good disintegration rate, meaning it breaks down well once flushed, reducing the risk of clogged pipes.
Another aspect that users have found favorable is the size of the rolls. They are reported to be larger than some other brands, which can mean fewer roll changes and potentially better value for money. However, some users have noted that the rolls may not fit all holders due to their size.
In terms of environmental impact, Cottonelle is recognized for sourcing its fibers responsibly and is certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). This commitment to sustainability is an important factor for eco-conscious consumers.